Crime and Justice Atlas

How Justice Is Served
Sign In
Text size
100%
Theme
Criminology Theories and Schools

Critical Criminology

Also Known As Radical Criminology
Critical and Conflict Theories

A tradition holding that legal and penal systems reproduce and uphold systems of social inequality, developed principally through Richard Quinney's Marxist analysis of crime and law. It reads criminal law and its enforcement as protecting the interests of the powerful and controlling marginalized populations, rather than as a neutral instrument of justice. This description is adapted from Wikipedia contributors under CC BY-SA 4.0; changes were made. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/

Facts
Core ClaimSourced to the subject's own account
Crime and criminal law are products of structural inequality, particularly class, and the criminal justice system functions to protect the interests of the powerful rather than as a neutral instrument of justice. 1
Standing CritiqueSourced to the subject's own account
Jock Young himself, writing in 1979, characterized the tradition's earliest form as left idealist, and the article notes this early criminology was never really popular in the United States. 1
Disputed
Origin Year
1974 1
Sourced to the subject's own accountThe movement crystallized gradually across the late 1960s and 1970s rather than on one founding date; 1974 marks Richard Quinney's Critique of Legal Order, a landmark work of the tradition rather than its sole origin.
Connections

Associated With

Corporate Manslaughter, Offenses

Critical criminology's central claim -- that crimes of the powerful are systematically under-punished relative to their harm -- is illustrated here by workplace deaths from employer negligence, the exact harm corporate manslaughter law targets.

Source Wikipedia: Critical Criminology

Feminist criminology shares critical criminology's structural, radical lineage, while its own literature also documents tension with a critical and Marxist criminology that was largely silent on gender.

Source Wikipedia: Feminist School of Criminology

Michael J. Lynch coined the term "green criminology" in 1990 as an extension of radical/critical criminology's political-economic analysis to environmental harm; he received the American Society of Criminology Critical Criminology Division's Lifetime Achievement Award.

Piers Beirne is a leading critical criminology scholar; his Inventing Criminology (1993) and, with James Messerschmidt, the widely used textbook Criminology: A Sociological Approach place critical criminology's history and method.

Source Wikipedia: William Chambliss

Critiqued Here

Left realism formed as an internal break from what its founders called the left idealism of earlier radical and critical criminology.

Source Wikipedia: Left Realism

Critical criminology rejects the positivist school's focus on individual pathology as the cause of crime, arguing crime and its definition are products of structural inequality instead.

Source Wikipedia: Critical Criminology

Developed By

Source Wikipedia: Critical Criminology

Informed By

Georg Rusche originated the labor-market analysis of punishment in a 1933 Frankfurt Institute article, expanded with Kirchheimer into Punishment and Social Structure (1939), the founding text of critical criminology's political-economy tradition.

George Vold's 1958 group conflict theory, explaining crime and lawmaking through competing interest groups rather than individual pathology, is widely cited as a direct precursor of conflict and critical criminology.

Otto Kirchheimer co-authored Punishment and Social Structure (1939) with Georg Rusche, the seminal Marxian political-economy analysis of punishment that founds critical criminology's materialist tradition.

Sources
1. Wikipedia: Critical Criminology
  • Lead section
    Legal and penal systems are understood to reproduce and uphold systems of social inequality.
  • Criticism section
    Early criminologies, pejoratively referred to as 'left idealist' by Jock Young 1979, were never really popular in the United States.
  • Associated With: Corporate Manslaughter, Socially contingent definitions of crime section
    one is seven times more likely (or was in 1983) to be killed as a result of negligence by one's employer, than one was to be murdered
  • In Group: Critical, Feminist and Left Realist Criminology, Lead
    Critical criminology examines the genesis of crime and the nature of justice in relation to power, privilege, and social status.
View the Source
Wikipedia: Feminist School of Criminology
Associated With: Feminist Criminology, History sectionView the Source
Wikipedia: Left Realism
Associated With: Left Realism, Establishment of left realism section
Quote, Associated With: Left Realism, Establishment of left realism section
Left Realism set down a marker in the United Kingdom with the work of Lea and Young (1984)
View the Source
Wikipedia: William Chambliss
Associated With: William Chambliss, Opening paragraph
Quote, Associated With: William Chambliss, Opening paragraph
He was a pioneer of the conflict theory (social theory) which concluded, among other things, that conflict between different social classes is the fundamental force in capitalist societies.
View the Source
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.